All results were obtained with the def2-QZVP basis set.
For each data point of the subset, the actual result in Eh and the
deviation from the reference value ("Res. - Ref."; in kcal/mol) are given.
At the end of the table, mean (MD), mean absolute (MAD), root mean square (RMSD),
maximum (max) and minimum (min) deviations are shown.
MD*, MAD*, RMSD*, max* and min* are the statistical values for the W4-08woMR subset.
The results were published in: Goerigk, L.; Grimme, S. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2010, 6, 107-126.
oPWLYP | oPWLYP-D | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
# | Result | Res. - Ref. | Result | Res. - Ref. |
1 | 603.74 | -3.2841 | 606.72 | -0.2981 |
2 | 414.19 | 3.2203 | 414.45 | 3.4833 |
3 | 473.85 | 2.8841 | 474.02 | 3.0521 |
4 | 708.08 | -5.0005 | 709.53 | -3.5455 |
5 | 354.77 | 11.0154 | 354.92 | 11.1684 |
6 | 523.88 | 21.8372 | 524.13 | 22.0872 |
7 | 490.20 | 7.9195 | 490.89 | 8.6075 |
8 | 481.89 | 7.2645 | 482.62 | 7.9865 |
9 | 585.00 | 2.6983 | 586.09 | 3.7893 |
10 | 267.41 | 8.6257 | 267.43 | 8.6487 |
11 | 244.01 | 19.1497 | 244.03 | 19.1677 |
12 | 311.10 | 14.5704 | 311.21 | 14.6844 |
13 | 449.56 | 11.2826 | 450.28 | 12.0046 |
14 | 166.43 | 31.7083 | 166.48 | 31.7633 |
15 | 195.19 | 42.8216 | 195.49 | 43.1236 |
16 | 425.76 | -5.2092 | 426.53 | -4.4422 |
17 | 522.11 | -13.7834 | 524.66 | -11.2304 |
18 | 288.57 | -2.0127 | 288.61 | -1.9657 |
19 | 269.99 | 9.3701 | 270.06 | 9.4361 |
20 | 357.39 | 10.4528 | 357.59 | 10.6468 |
21 | 346.51 | 10.7566 | 346.58 | 10.8266 |
22 | 287.91 | 7.1277 | 288.04 | 7.2647 |
23 | 216.87 | 8.0855 | 216.99 | 8.2085 |
24 | 172.72 | 4.3593 | 172.94 | 4.5843 |
25 | 240.02 | 5.6673 | 240.51 | 6.1603 |
26 | 223.60 | -1.6659 | 224.02 | -1.2509 |
27 | 180.51 | 3.1513 | 180.58 | 3.2193 |
28 | 293.65 | -18.9963 | 294.90 | -17.7463 |
29 | 294.81 | 9.3628 | 294.92 | 9.4718 |
30 | 147.69 | 19.5706 | 147.77 | 19.6476 |
31 | 151.95 | 25.5580 | 152.10 | 25.7060 |
32 | 110.70 | 9.2433 | 110.77 | 9.3113 |
33 | 108.16 | -1.3292 | 108.16 | -1.3282 |
34 | 109.79 | 2.5811 | 109.79 | 2.5821 |
35 | 141.47 | -0.1691 | 141.47 | -0.1681 |
36 | 233.33 | 0.3590 | 233.34 | 0.3710 |
37 | 85.25 | 1.0305 | 85.25 | 1.0315 |
38 | 190.79 | 0.0503 | 190.93 | 0.1933 |
39 | 308.00 | 0.1327 | 308.25 | 0.3797 |
40 | 418.25 | -2.1691 | 418.55 | -1.8701 |
41 | 268.31 | 2.1525 | 268.40 | 2.2355 |
42 | 407.32 | 1.8030 | 407.51 | 1.9880 |
43 | 302.27 | 4.2511 | 302.33 | 4.3121 |
44 | 135.94 | -11.0838 | 135.94 | -11.0828 |
45 | 234.56 | 6.0836 | 234.56 | 6.0846 |
46 | 263.34 | 3.6051 | 263.34 | 3.6061 |
47 | 192.13 | 10.7832 | 192.13 | 10.7842 |
48 | 167.21 | 14.4606 | 167.21 | 14.4616 |
49 | 137.28 | 16.4616 | 137.28 | 16.4626 |
50 | 68.54 | 15.4625 | 68.54 | 15.4635 |
51 | 50.27 | 11.2334 | 50.28 | 11.2354 |
52 | 242.77 | 0.5002 | 243.33 | 1.0612 |
53 | 87.97 | 0.2435 | 87.97 | 0.2445 |
54 | 181.38 | -2.5260 | 181.50 | -2.4110 |
55 | 104.96 | -2.5387 | 104.96 | -2.5377 |
56 | 136.73 | 10.2614 | 136.73 | 10.2624 |
57 | 76.28 | 10.8328 | 76.28 | 10.8338 |
58 | 68.69 | 5.8929 | 68.69 | 5.8949 |
59 | 122.17 | 4.5803 | 122.17 | 4.5843 |
60 | 109.41 | 5.1604 | 109.41 | 5.1634 |
61 | 59.94 | 0.1917 | 59.95 | 0.1967 |
62 | 6.69 | 4.0221 | 6.77 | 4.0961 |
63 | 68.58 | 1.1204 | 68.58 | 1.1234 |
64 | 82.71 | -2.2817 | 82.71 | -2.2807 |
65 | 280.99 | -0.2954 | 281.55 | 0.2636 |
66 | 109.07 | 3.8287 | 109.07 | 3.8297 |
67 | 184.73 | 2.2140 | 184.73 | 2.2150 |
68 | 89.16 | 6.0619 | 89.16 | 6.0629 |
69 | 189.38 | 6.7914 | 189.40 | 6.8104 |
70 | 321.52 | 8.1043 | 321.60 | 8.1833 |
71 | 169.38 | 10.7273 | 169.40 | 10.7483 |
72 | 71.66 | -1.9112 | 71.66 | -1.9062 |
73 | 207.98 | -5.1942 | 208.22 | -4.9522 |
74 | 163.11 | -0.6719 | 163.11 | -0.6689 |
75 | 117.82 | -4.7966 | 117.83 | -4.7866 |
76 | 74.09 | 0.1684 | 74.09 | 0.1704 |
77 | 318.17 | -6.7766 | 319.15 | -5.8016 |
78 | 196.70 | 3.6511 | 196.70 | 3.6521 |
79 | 146.27 | 3.5629 | 146.27 | 3.5649 |
80 | 173.22 | 1.0004 | 173.22 | 1.0014 |
81 | 119.34 | 13.5195 | 119.34 | 13.5205 |
82 | 140.68 | 7.9625 | 140.68 | 7.9635 |
83 | 316.38 | 7.2777 | 316.63 | 7.5337 |
84 | 363.17 | 3.2428 | 363.33 | 3.3958 |
85 | 449.48 | 3.3983 | 449.82 | 3.7383 |
86 | 563.74 | -0.3630 | 564.41 | 0.3090 |
87 | 446.74 | 7.3034 | 447.18 | 7.7424 |
88 | 289.18 | 9.7618 | 289.22 | 9.7978 |
89 | 380.06 | 5.4009 | 380.21 | 5.5509 |
90 | 403.32 | 13.1781 | 403.35 | 13.2131 |
91 | 218.78 | 12.8864 | 218.79 | 12.9004 |
92 | 257.41 | 29.5296 | 257.43 | 29.5506 |
93 | 299.11 | 28.2613 | 299.14 | 28.2933 |
94 | 173.11 | 25.6785 | 173.13 | 25.6965 |
95 | 190.25 | 14.7216 | 190.27 | 14.7356 |
96 | 278.11 | 9.0243 | 278.32 | 9.2303 |
97 | 117.04 | 23.2615 | 117.08 | 23.3045 |
98 | 170.55 | 4.3238 | 170.58 | 4.3478 |
99 | 167.34 | 2.2105 | 167.47 | 2.3445 |
MD | 6.22 | 6.45 | ||
MAD | 8.08 | 8.07 | ||
RMSD | 11.30 | 11.30 | ||
max | 42.82 | 43.12 | ||
min | -19.00 | -17.75 | ||
MD* | 4.70 | 4.95 | ||
MAD* | 6.65 | 6.61 | ||
RMSD* | 9.00 | 8.97 | ||
max* | 29.53 | 29.55 | ||
min* | -19.00 | -17.75 |